games   movies   music

forums   links   store





Do you like to play video games?

Catch the live games by purchasing tickets to all MLB games including Yankees and Mets. BuySellTix also has tickets to all concerts including Dave Matthews Band.

Download the PLANET42 / Alexa Toolbar

Musicmatch Jukebox 8.2 featuring music downloads!

Looking for work? Visit HotJobs.com

Lik-Sang.com

BuyDVD.com - Online anime superstore!

12ALL Broadcast E-mail

Review By:

Macgyver

Review Date:

10/31/2003

Director:

Jean-Pierre Jeunet

Writer:

Joss Whedon

Starring:

Sigourney Weaver, Brad Dourif,
Winona Ryder, Ron Perlman,
Michael Wincott

Rating: 2 out of 5 Planets


Intro:
This week I have been reviewing the Alien saga, due to the release of the ALIEN: YAY, WOOHOO, YIPPEE! Directors Cut. And today it’s the turn of the film that makes me wish I could call it the Alien trilogy. That’s right, time for the Resurrection...

Review:
Ripley dies at the end of Alien 3 (sorry for the spoiler). That causes a slight problem for a sequel, as your main character is gone. But it’s okay, because they clone her. Then...oh I can’t be bothered.

I HATE THIS MOVIE! I could just write that about 1000 times and post it, but that would be lazy. And I don’t want to hate it. Joss Whedon wrote it. He’s done good things in his career. We’ll ignore Titan AE for a moment, but there’s Buffy (film and TV show), Angel, Toy Story and possibly some future goodness. This is just bad writing though.

Ripley died by falling in to a furnace in Alien 3. It’s kind of hard to get DNA from that. I can buy that they had some on file, or that they got some from the infirmary in Alien 3. BUT when you clone someone, stuff that is inside his or her body doesn’t magically appear! If you clone me right now, the contents of the cup of tea and a biscuit I just had will not be in my stomach. But Ripley’s little Alien queen gets cloned too.

That’s fuzzy science on a level that Voyager didn’t even stoop too. And somehow the Alien DNA and Ripley’s DNA got mixed up. I can understand a little bit of blood getting mixed together while it’s growing, but that DOESN’T CHANGE YOUR DNA! Otherwise women who are pregnant would start being all freaky on a genetic level. It means that Ripley has a bit of alien in her, and acidic blood somehow (why she doesn’t melt I don’t know) and vice versa.

Stuff and Nonsense:
And the Aliens look terrible in this. I’m pretty sure they are all CG, though I could be wrong, but they just plain look bad. Sure, they are shinier and sleeker looking but they don’t look like they should be in place. And for the next bit of rant I need to hit spoiler territory so if you haven’t seen this flop and still want to, skip the next paragraph.

When the Alien queen gives birth to the half human/half alien it looks horrible. I don’t know where to begin on this monstrosity. It does look kind of cute a couple of times, but it just shouldn’t be. There’s no need for it. It’s basically a big pink alien, though it looks a little like a baby dinosaur for some reason. And it thinks Ripley is mommy. WHY? It just came out of, then killed, mommy. Ripley looks nothing like it. And if it’s going by smell it’s covered in goo so it should STILL go for her. Animals latch on to the first thing they see, and that wasn’t Ripley...

And there are also the. They actually provide a couple of the good things about this movie. But they also contain one of the pointless characters. Why, oh why is one of them in a wheelchair? It doesn’t aid the plot in any way. And the one moment it kind of does, could have easily been achieved by having someone get shot on the leg and need to be carried. It’s like an executive thought it would be politically correct to have a handicapped person in the movie? And I can’t find any evidence that Dominique Pinon is disabled either. He’s French but that’s not quite the same thing... If he is then fair enough, I have no problem with disabled actors in ANY movie. But if it was just for a gimmick give me a break!

Michael Wincott (Top Dollar from the Crow) is one of the good things about this movie, of which there are roughly two and a half. He plays the lead mercenary, Elgyn, and is finally more than a scratchy voiced bad guy (though he’s great at that). His character is somewhat sympathetic, but gets hosed way too early.

Ron Perlman (#2 good thing, Dieter in Blade II) is the smart-ass who wants to sleep with anything he sees, and shoot anything he can’t sleep with. He gets all the good lines in the movie (there are plenty) and doesn’t get killed too early (or at all, though I won’t say which). The character is basically the same as Blade II, tool.

And finally the half a planet thing. Ripley. Sigourney is good in this and she plays the weird, slightly “Alien” Ripley quite well. If you look at it the way I did. I assumed that the process of being cloned 200 years after you killed yourself, and finding out you have saved the species you hate, and getting some of its DNA in your blood makes you a little nuts. A little bit fruity. And that’s how it’s played. Occasionally she’s a bit too alien, but generally it’s okay. And for a 48-year-old she is pretty fine here too.

Oh, and Brad Dourif is good here too. He always is though so I won’t count it. That’s like saying Lance Henriksen was good in 3, it’s a given. But that is IT. Some of the sets are very pretty, and the movie is decently directed by Jean-Pierre Jeunet, a man who hasn’t been allowed to shoot anything else in English before or since (bad Jean-Pierre, bad!) but it doesn’t cut it. If your going to join a series that the other directors are Ridley Scott, James Cameron and David Fincher you better be better than decent.

Conclusion:
Maybe that’s the problem. The French killed the alien series with a little help from Joss Whedon. This film is only in my house, and I’m betting the same goes for many others, because it came in a box set with the rest and that was the cheapest way to get them. I can’t think of why anyone would buy this separately. All together now: one, two, three: ARGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHH!

That’s it for the Alien saga. I won’t be getting a chance to see the Directors Cut in the cinema due to the aforementioned pub visit eating up all my funds. However, next weeks big movie is MATRIX: REVOLUTIONS! This means a Matrix review rush for this week. And yes I have tickets! Revolutions opens worldwide on Wednesday. Then I can take a couple of days off, right? That would be nice...


MacGyver Rating: 2 out of 5 Planets


Talk about Alien Resurrection>>
 

PLANET42 Toolbar | Staff Members | Privacy Policy  | Advertise | Jobs | Contact
Copyright © 2001 - 2004 PLANET42.COM. All Rights Reserved.

Design by StyleWright